The statement “All Lives Matter” in response to “Black Lives Matter” is entirely inadequate. It misses the mark by 401 years. “All Lives Matter” bears little resemblance to the lived reality of black and brown people since America’s founding. ALM is either tragically uninformed or dishonest about how our country with the church’s blessing and participation, has worked systematically, legally, economically, politically, academically, theologically and ecclesiastically to un-matter blacks lives.
Given the soaring words of scripture and our nation’s founding documents, the very need of a segment of the population to have to assert that they matter is the very evidence of the presence and success of this un-mattering. The need to cry out that one matters is a vivid failure of our fidelity to both holy scripture and our nation’s founding documents!
ALM is well intentioned but aspirational. Native, female, Hispanic, poor, immigrant, incarcerated and gay lives at present do not equally matter according to hiring, health care, wages, budgets, policies, policing, public services, public schools or political representation.
But this inequity is just a symptom of a “…far deeper malady within the American spirit.” Black lives and other lives are being un-mattered because of the persistent implementation of sin that “ …so easily ensnares us.” Sin is the conscious and unconscious un-mattering of God, of one another and of our planet.
In defiance of this human tendency to un-matter people, didn’t Jesus, all over Galilee, at the Cross and after his Resurrection, matter people? Isn’t that why his words and example continue to soften our hearts and save us from the status quo?
If progress with integrity and spiritual wholeness are our goals, then we will have to summon up a supernatural amount of maturity to confess what we “have done and left undone,” and embark on a “revolution of values” with measurable outcomes.
So, by the Spirit’s power, let us continue to work to hurry-up the day when every American and every inhabitant of the planet can say “All lives Matter” and it be demonstrably true. Until then, justice, truth and fidelity demand that we stand with the un-mattered and affirm “Black Lives Matter.”
For People with Bishop Rob Wright
The new podcast expands on Bishop’s For Faith devotional, drawing inspiration from the life of Jesus to answer 21st-century questions.